Theta dependence, sign problems and topological interference

Abstract: In a Euclidean path integral formulation of gauge theory and quantum mechanics, the theta-term induces a sign problem, and relatedly, a complex phase for the fugacity of topological defects; whereas in Minkowskian formulation, it induces a topological (geometric) phase multiplying ordinary path-amplitudes. In an SU(2) Yang-Mills theory which admits a semi-classical limit, we show that the complex fugacity generates interference between Euclidean path histories, i.e., monopole-instanton events, and radically alters the vacuum structure. At theta=0, a mass gap is due to the monopole-instanton plasma, and the theory has a unique vacuum. At theta=pi, the monopole induced mass gap vanishes, despite the fact that monopole density is independent of theta, due to destructive topological interference. The theory has two options: to remain gapless or to be gapped with a two-fold degenerate vacua. We show the latter is realized by the magnetic bion mechanism, and the two-vacua are realization of spontaneous CP-breaking. The effect of the theta-term in the circle-compactified gauge theory is a generalization of Aharonov-Bohm effect, and the geometric (Berry) phase. As theta varies from 0 to pi, the gauge theory interpolates between even- and odd-integer spin quantum anti-ferromagnets on two spatial dimensional bi-partite lattices, which have ground state degeneracies one and two, respectively, as it is in gauge theory at theta=0 and theta=pi.