Communication vs Distributed Computation: an alternative trade-off curve

Abstract: In this paper, we revisit the communication vs. distributed computing trade-off, studied within the framework of MapReduce in [1]. An implicit assumption in the aforementioned work is that each server performs all possible computations on all the files stored in its memory. Our starting observation is that, if servers can compute only the intermediate values they need, then storage constraints do not directly imply computation constraints. We examine how this affects the communication-computation trade-off and suggest that the trade-off be studied with a predetermined storage constraint. We then proceed to examine the case where servers need to perform computationally intensive tasks, and may not have sufficient time to perform all computations required by the scheme in [1]. Given a threshold that limits the computational load, we derive a lower bound on the associated communication load, and propose a heuristic scheme that achieves in some cases the lower bound.