Cosmological Hydrodynamic Simulations with Suppressed Variance in the Lyman-$α$ Forest Power Spectrum

Abstract: We test a method to reduce unwanted sample variance when predicting Lyman-$\alpha$ (ly$\alpha$) forest power spectra from cosmological hydrodynamical simulations. Sample variance arises due to sparse sampling of modes on large scales and propagates to small scales through non-linear gravitational evolution. To tackle this, we generate initial conditions in which the density perturbation amplitudes are {\it fixed} to the ensemble average power spectrum -- and are generated in {\it pairs} with exactly opposite phases. We run $50$ such simulations ($25$ pairs) and compare their performance against $50$ standard simulations by measuring the ly$\alpha$ 1D and 3D power spectra at redshifts $z=2$, 3, and 4. Both ensembles use periodic boxes of $40$ Mpc/h containing $512^3$ particles each of dark matter and gas. As a typical example of improvement, for wavenumbers $k=0.25$ h/Mpc at $z=3$, we find estimates of the 1D and 3D power spectra converge $34$ and $12$ times faster in a paired-fixed ensemble compared with a standard ensemble. We conclude that, by reducing the computational time required to achieve fixed accuracy on predicted power spectra, the method frees up resources for exploration of varying thermal and cosmological parameters -- ultimately allowing the improved precision and accuracy of statistical inference.