Micro-reversibility and thermalization with collisional baths

Abstract: Micro-reversibility, that is, the time reversal symmetry exhibited by microscopic dynamics, plays a central role in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics. It is used to prove fundamental results such as Onsager reciprocal relations or fluctuation theorems. From micro-reversibility one can also prove that isolated systems and systems in contact with a thermal bath relax to micro-canonical and canonical ensembles, respectively. However, a number of problems arise when trying to reproduce this proof for classical and quantum collisional baths, consisting of particles from an equilibrium reservoir interacting with a localized system via collisions. In particular, it is not completely clear which distribution for the velocities of the incident particles warrants thermalization. Here, we clarify these issues by showing that Liouville's theorem is a necessary condition for micro-reversibility in classical and semi-classical scenarios. As a consequence, one must take into account all the canonical coordinates and momenta, including the position of the incident particles. Taking into account the position modifies the effective probability distribution of the velocity of the particles that interact with the system, which is no longer Maxwellian. We finally show an example of seemingly plausible collision rules that nonetheless violate the Liouville theorem and allow one to design machines that beat the second law of thermodynamics.