Expected Sarsa($λ$) with Control Variate for Variance Reduction

Abstract: Off-policy learning is powerful for reinforcement learning. However, the high variance of off-policy evaluation is a critical challenge, which causes off-policy learning falls into an uncontrolled instability. In this paper, for reducing the variance, we introduce control variate technique to $\mathtt{Expected}$ $\mathtt{Sarsa}$($\lambda$) and propose a tabular $\mathtt{ES}$($\lambda$)-$\mathtt{CV}$ algorithm. We prove that if a proper estimator of value function reaches, the proposed $\mathtt{ES}$($\lambda$)-$\mathtt{CV}$ enjoys a lower variance than $\mathtt{Expected}$ $\mathtt{Sarsa}$($\lambda$). Furthermore, to extend $\mathtt{ES}$($\lambda$)-$\mathtt{CV}$ to be a convergent algorithm with linear function approximation, we propose the $\mathtt{GES}$($\lambda$) algorithm under the convex-concave saddle-point formulation. We prove that the convergence rate of $\mathtt{GES}$($\lambda$) achieves $\mathcal{O}(1/T)$, which matches or outperforms lots of state-of-art gradient-based algorithms, but we use a more relaxed condition. Numerical experiments show that the proposed algorithm performs better with lower variance than several state-of-art gradient-based TD learning algorithms: $\mathtt{GQ}$($\lambda$), $\mathtt{GTB}$($\lambda$) and $\mathtt{ABQ}$($\zeta$).