Observation of Magic Angle and Wall State in Twisted Bilayer Photonic Graphene

Abstract: Graphene, a one-layer honeycomb lattice of carbon atoms, exhibits unconventional phenomena and attracts much interest since its discovery. Recently, an unexpected Mott-like insulator state induced by moir\'e pattern and a superconducting state are observed in magic-angle-twisted bilayer graphene, especially, without correlations between electrons, which gives more hints for the understanding and investigation of strongly correlated phenomena. The photon as boson, behaving differently with fermion, can also retrieve the unconventional phenomena of graphene, such as the bearded edge state which is even never been observed in graphene due to the unstability. Here, we present a direct observation of magic angle and wall state in twisted bilayer photonic graphene. We successfully observe the strong localization and rapid diffusion of photon at the regions with AA and AB stacking order around the magic angle, respectively. Most importantly, we find a wall state showing the photon distribution distinctly separate at the regions with AA and AB/BA stacking order in the lowest-energy band. The mechanism underlying the wall states may help to understand the existence of both Mott-like insulating state and superconducting state in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene. The accessibility of magic angle in twisted bilayer photonic graphene adds the boson behavior into graphene superlattice and the observation of wall state will also deep the understanding of matter.