Engines of Parsimony: Part I; Limits on Computational Rates in Physical Systems

Abstract: We analyse the maximum achievable rate of sustained computation for a given convex region of three dimensional space subject to geometric constraints on power delivery and heat dissipation. We find a universal upper bound across both quantum and classical systems, scaling as $\sqrt{AV}$ where $V$ is the region volume and $A$ its area. Attaining this bound requires the use of reversible computation, else it falls to scaling as $A$. By specialising our analysis to the case of Brownian classical systems, we also give a semi-constructive proof suggestive of an implementation attaining these bounds by means of molecular computers. For regions of astronomical size, general relativistic effects become significant and more restrictive bounds proportional to $\sqrt{AR}$ and $R$ are found to apply, where $R$ is its radius. It is also shown that inhomogeneity in computational structure is generally to be avoided. These results are depicted graphically in Figure 1.