Studying physics during the COVID-19 pandemic: Student assessments of learning achievement, perceived effectiveness of online recitations, and online laboratories

Abstract: The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly affected the education system worldwide that was responding with a sudden shift to distance learning. Various physics courses such as lectures, tutorials, and the laboratories had to be transferred into online formats rapidly, resulting in a variety of simultaneous, asynchronous, and mixed activities. To investigate how physics students perceived the sudden shift to online learning, we developed a questionnaire and gathered data from N = 578 physics students from five universities in Germany, Austria, and Croatia. In this article, we report how the problem-solving sessions (recitations) and laboratories were adapted, how students' judge different formats of the courses and how useful and effective they perceive them. The results are correlated to the students' self-efficacy ratings and other behavioral measures (such as self-regulated learning skills) and demographics. In a related article, we focus on the online physics lectures and compare simultaneous vs. asynchronous teaching and learning methods (n.n.). We find that good communication abilities and self-organization skills are positively correlated for perceived learning achievement. Furthermore, the previous duration of studies had a significant impact on the students' perceived overall learning achievement, on the students' acquisition of experimental skills during the physics laboratories, and on their assessment of the recitations' effectiveness. That is, students in their first academic year show consistently lower scores than more progressed students. For the physics laboratories, it was found that gathering real data was crucial to the acquisition of experimental skills and the reinforcement of content. For the physics recitations, handing in own solutions for feedback was correlated with perceived effectiveness. We draw conclusions and implications for future online classes.