Simulations for the Q statistic with constant and inverse variance weights for binary effect measures

Abstract: Cochran's $Q$ statistic is routinely used for testing heterogeneity in meta-analysis. Its expected value (under an incorrect null distribution) is part of several popular estimators of the between-study variance, $\tau^2$. Those applications generally do not account for the studies' use of estimated variances in the inverse-variance weights that define $Q$ (more explicitly, $Q_{IV}$). Importantly, those weights make approximating the distribution of $Q_{IV}$ rather complicated. As an alternative, we are investigating a $Q$ statistic, $Q_F$, whose constant weights use only the studies' arm-level sample sizes. For log-odds-ratio, log-relative-risk, and risk difference as the measure of effect, these simulations study approximations to the distributions of $Q_F$ and $Q_{IV}$, as the basis for tests of heterogeneity. We present the results in 132 Figures, 153 pages in total.