The Impact of a Continuous Integration Service on the Delivery Time of Merged Pull Requests

Abstract: Continuous Integration (CI) is a software development practice that builds and tests software frequently (e.g., at every push). One main motivator to adopt CI is the potential to deliver software functionalities more quickly than not using CI. However, there is little empirical evidence to support that CI helps projects deliver software functionalities more quickly. Through the analysis of 162,653 pull requests (PRs) of 87 GitHub projects, we empirically study whether adopting a CI service (TravisCI) can quicken the time to deliver merged PRs. We complement our quantitative study by analyzing 450 survey responses from participants of 73 software projects. Our results reveal that adopting a CI service may not necessarily quicken the delivery of merge PRs. Instead, the pivotal benefit of a CI service is to improve the decision making on PR submissions, without compromising the quality or overloading the project's reviewers and maintainers. The automation provided by CI and the boost in developers' confidence are key advantages of adopting a CI service. Furthermore, open-source projects planning to attract and retain developers should consider the use of a CI service in their project, since CI is perceived to lower the contribution barrier while making contributors feel more confident and engaged in the project.