How Secure is Your Website? A Comprehensive Investigation on CAPTCHA Providers and Solving Services

Abstract: Completely Automated Public Turing Test To Tell Computers and Humans Apart (CAPTCHA) has been implemented on many websites to identify between harmful automated bots and legitimate users. However, the revenue generated by the bots has turned circumventing CAPTCHAs into a lucrative business. Although earlier studies provided information about text-based CAPTCHAs and the associated CAPTCHA-solving services, a lot has changed in the past decade regarding content, suppliers, and solvers of CAPTCHA. We have conducted a comprehensive investigation of the latest third-party CAPTCHA providers and CAPTCHA-solving services' attacks. We dug into the details of CAPTCHA-As-a-Service and the latest CAPTCHA-solving services and carried out adversarial experiments on CAPTCHAs and CAPTCHA solvers. The experiment results show a worrying fact: most latest CAPTCHAs are vulnerable to both human solvers and automated solvers. New CAPTCHAs based on hard AI problems and behavior analysis are needed to stop CAPTCHA solvers.