A Two-Stage Bayesian Small Area Estimation Approach for Proportions

Abstract: With the rise in popularity of digital Atlases to communicate spatial variation, there is an increasing need for robust small-area estimates. However, current small-area estimation methods suffer from various modeling problems when data are very sparse or when estimates are required for areas with very small populations. These issues are particularly heightened when modeling proportions. Additionally, recent work has shown significant benefits in modeling at both the individual and area levels. We propose a two-stage Bayesian hierarchical small area estimation approach for proportions that can: account for survey design; reduce direct estimate instability; and generate prevalence estimates for small areas with no survey data. Using a simulation study we show that, compared with existing Bayesian small area estimation methods, our approach can provide optimal predictive performance (Bayesian mean relative root mean squared error, mean absolute relative bias and coverage) of proportions under a variety of data conditions, including very sparse and unstable data. To assess the model in practice, we compare modeled estimates of current smoking prevalence for 1,630 small areas in Australia using the 2017-2018 National Health Survey data combined with 2016 census data.