MAFALDA: A Benchmark and Comprehensive Study of Fallacy Detection and Classification

Abstract: We introduce MAFALDA, a benchmark for fallacy classification that merges and unites previous fallacy datasets. It comes with a taxonomy that aligns, refines, and unifies existing classifications of fallacies. We further provide a manual annotation of a part of the dataset together with manual explanations for each annotation. We propose a new annotation scheme tailored for subjective NLP tasks, and a new evaluation method designed to handle subjectivity. We then evaluate several LLMs under a zero-shot learning setting and human performances on MAFALDA to assess their capability to detect and classify fallacies.