Classical Stability Margins by PID Control

Abstract: Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) control has been the workhorse of control technology for about a century. Yet to this day, designing and tuning PID controllers relies mostly on either tabulated rules (Ziegler-Nichols) or on classical graphical techniques (Bode). Our goal in this paper is to take a fresh look on PID control in the context of optimizing stability margins for low-order (first- and second-order) linear time-invariant systems. Specifically, we seek to derive explicit expressions for gain and phase margins that are achievable using PID control, and thereby gain insights on the role of unstable poles and nonminimum-phase zeros in attaining robust stability. In particular, stability margins attained by PID control for minimum-phase systems match those obtained by more general control, while for nonminimum-phase systems, PID control achieves margins that are no worse than those of general control modulo a predetermined factor. Furthermore, integral action does not contribute to robust stabilization beyond what can be achieved by PD control alone.