From High to Low: Simulating Nondeterminism and State with State

Abstract: Some effects are considered to be higher-level than others. High-level effects provide expressive and succinct abstraction of programming concepts, while low-level effects allow more fine-grained control over program execution and resources. Yet, often it is desirable to write programs using the convenient abstraction offered by high-level effects, and meanwhile still benefit from the optimisations enabled by low-level effects. One solution is to translate high-level effects to low-level ones. This paper studies how algebraic effects and handlers allow us to simulate high-level effects in terms of low-level effects. In particular, we focus on the interaction between state and nondeterminism known as the local state, as provided by Prolog. We map this high-level semantics in successive steps onto a low-level composite state effect, similar to that managed by Prolog's Warren Abstract Machine. We first give a translation from the high-level local-state semantics to the low-level global-state semantics, by explicitly restoring state updates on backtracking. Next, we eliminate nondeterminsm altogether in favor of a lower-level state containing a choicepoint stack. Then we avoid copying the state by restricting ourselves to incremental, reversible state updates. We show how these updates can be stored on a trail stack with another state effect. We prove the correctness of all our steps using program calculation where the fusion laws of effect handlers play a central role.