Property $P_{\text{naive}}$ for big mapping class groups

Abstract: We study the property $P_{\text {naive }}$ of mapping class groups of surfaces of infinite type, that is, for any finite collection of non-trivial elements $h_{1},h_{2}, \cdots, h_{n}$, there exists another element $g\neq 1$ of infinite order such that for all $i$, $\langle g, h_{i}\rangle \cong \langle g \rangle * \langle h_{i} \rangle$.