Bounding the Error of Value Functions in Sobolev Norm Yields Bounds on Suboptimality of Controller Performance

Abstract: Optimal feedback controllers for nonlinear systems can be derived by solving the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equation. However, because the HJB is a nonlinear partial differential equation, in general only approximate solutions can be numerically found. While numerical error bounds on approximate HJB solutions are often available, we show that these bounds do not necessarily translate into guarantees on the suboptimality of the resulting controllers. In this paper, we establish that if the numerical error in the HJB solution can be bounded in a Sobolev norm, a norm involving spatial derivatives, then the suboptimality of the corresponding feedback controller can also be bounded, and this bound can be made arbitrarily small. In contrast, we demonstrate that such guarantees do not hold when the error is measured in more typical norms, such as the uniform norm ($L^\infty$). Our results apply to systems governed by locally Lipschitz continuous dynamics over a finite time horizon with a compact input space. Numerical examples are provided to illustrate the theoretical findings.