Universal energy cascade in homogeneous binary fluid turbulence: A direct comparison of different exact relations

Abstract: Below critical temperature, turbulence prevents the spontaneous phase separation of binary mixtures, resulting in a phase arrested state of emulsion which is of significant interest for scientific and industrial applications. The current work is an extensive continuation of our initial theoretical investigation into the nature and universality of associated energy cascade (Pan and Banerjee, PRE, 2022). In addition to the previously derived divergence and correlator forms of the exact relations, a Banerjee-Galtier type divergence-free form of the exact relation is derived under the explicit assumption of homogeneity. By performing three-dimensional direct numerical simulations with up to $1024^3$ grid points, we show that the sum of the kinetic and active energy associates a Kolmogorov-like universal cascade with constant flux rate across inertial scales. Despite term-by-term deviations, the cascade rates computed from all three exact laws show excellent agreement, thereby confirming the equivalence of different exact relations and hence the feasibility of determining the net cascade rate from any of the three formulations. Notably, the two dominant flux rates of the divergence form are found to cross each other roughly at the domain size, which also serves as an infrared cut-off for the inverse cascade of the small scale active energy. This behaviour is phenomenologically justified based on the interplay between the flow and surface dynamics of a phase arrested binary fluid.