What causes long outbursts of neutron star low-mass X-ray binaries?

Abstract: Many neutron star low-mass X-ray binaries (NS LMXBs) with short orbital periods (~hours) cycle between outburst and quiescent phases, and thus provide an excellent way to study the accretion process. The cause of such outbursts is believed to be thermal-viscous instability in the accretion disc. However, some of these transient sources show unusually long outbursts. For example, EXO 0748-676 remained in outburst for at least 23 years before entering a quiescence, only to re-emerge 16 years later. We aim to investigate if such long outbursts could be due to the usual disc instability, or if any other mechanism is required. In order to address this question, we systematically compare various properties of long outburst and short outburst NS LMXBs. For this, we analyze the long-term X-ray light curves of many short orbital period (hours) NS LMXBs, examining the outburst duration and the inferred accretion rate, and estimate the accretion disc mass. Our study shows that long outburst sources are well-separated from the short outburst ones in parameter spaces involving accretion rate, disc mass, outburst duration, etc. in four ways. This implies that the thermal-viscous instability in the disc cannot explain the long outbursts, but could explain the short ones. Moreover, we discuss that both donor star related and disc related models have difficulties in explaining long outbursts. Our finding will be crucial to understanding the accretion process of transiently accreting neutron stars and black holes.