Generalizing the relativistic precession model of quasi-periodic oscillations through anharmonic corrections

Abstract: We critically reanalyze the relativistic precession model of quasi-periodic oscillations, exploring its natural extension beyond the standard harmonic approximation. To do so, we show that the perturbed geodesic equations must include anharmonic contributions arising from the higher-order expansion of the effective potential that cannot be neglected \emph{a priori}, as commonly done in all the approaches pursued so far. More specifically, independently of the underlying spacetime geometry, we find that in the radial sector the non-negligible anharmonic correction is quadratic in the radial displacement, i.e. $\propto \delta r^2$, and significantly affects the radial epicyclic frequency close to the innermost stable circular orbit. Conversely, polar oscillations $\delta \theta$ remain approximately decoupled from radial ones, preserving their independent dynamical behavior. To show the need of anharmonic corrections, we thus carry out Monte Carlo-Markov chain analyses on eight neutron star sources of quasi-periodic oscillations. Afterwards, we first work out the outcomes of the harmonic approximation in Schwarzschild, Schwarzschild--de Sitter, and Kerr spacetimes. Subsequently, we apply the anharmonic corrections to them and use it to fit the aforementioned neutron star sources. Our findings indicate that the standard paradigm requires a systematic generalization to include the leading anharmonic corrections that appear physically necessary, although still insufficient to fully account for the observed phenomenology of quasi-periodic oscillations. Accordingly, we speculate on possible refinements of the relativistic precession model, showing the need to revise it at a fundamental level.