Dual system estimation using mixed effects loglinear models

Abstract: In official statistics, dual system estimation (DSE) is a well-known tool to estimate the size of a population. Two sources are linked, and the number of units that are missed by both sources is estimated. Often dual system estimation is carried out in each of the levels of a stratifying variable, such as region. DSE can be considered a loglinear independence model, and, with a stratifying variable, a loglinear conditional independence model. The standard approach is to estimate parameters for each level of the stratifying variable. Thus, when the number of levels of the stratifying variable is large, the number of parameters estimated is large as well. Mixed effects loglinear models, where sets of parameters involving the stratifying variable are replaced by a distribution parameterised by its mean and a variance, have also been proposed, and we investigate their properties through simulation. In our simulation studies the mixed effects loglinear model outperforms the fixed effects loglinear model although only to a small extent in terms of mean squared error. We show how mixed effects dual system estimation can be extended to multiple system estimation.