Engineering Emergence

Abstract: One of the reasons complex systems are complex is because they have multiscale structure. How does this multiscale structure come about? We argue that it reflects an emergent hierarchy of scales that contribute to the system's causal workings. An example is how a computer can be described at the level of its hardware circuitry but also its software. But we show that many systems, even simple ones, have such an emergent hierarchy, built from a small subset of all their possible scales of description. Formally, we extend the theory of causal emergence (2.0) so as to analyze the causal contributions across the full multiscale structure of a system rather than just over a single path that traverses the system's scales. Our methods reveal that systems can be classified as being causally top-heavy or bottom-heavy, or their emergent hierarchies can be highly complex. We argue that this provides a more specific notion of scale-freeness (here, when causation is spread equally across the scales of a system) than the standard network science terminology. More broadly, we provide the mathematical tools to quantify this complexity and provide diverse examples of the taxonomy of emergent hierarchies. Finally, we demonstrate the ability to engineer not just degree of emergence in a system, but how that emergence is distributed across the multiscale structure.